|
Melamine is is a low quality plastic coating that is put
on hardboard or medium density fiberboard (MDF). It was developed as
a low cost coating to approximate paint on low cost furniture.
It also happens to allow dry erase markers to be used on it "for a while".
The surface is not very hard , wears quickly and the markers will over
time seep thru the melamine and stain the wood so that there is permanent
ghosting.
5 years ago there was only Melamine and ceramic steel as
choices but today there are many options for dry erase material priced
between melamine and ceramic steel (the longest wearing time proven
surface). Melamine is price at a bout a 1/3 of ceramic steel
but really not recommended.
1.
How do
MarkaWall
products compare to melamine and porcelain?
Melamine is mainly used for small “throw-away” type boards found at office
supply and discount stores. Melamine is either a sprayed on or coated
plastic surface on 1/8” or 1/4" hardboard. It is also available as a
high-pressure laminate (similar to Formica counter top). Melamine can
stain easily and certain chemicals may damage the surface. Permanent
markers usually cannot be removed from the surface. Melamine is meant to
be an inexpensive surface that can be thrown away. It rarely is used in
full wall applications and it is usually framed with wood or aluminum
trim. Standard size of melamine sheets is 4’ x 8’, but it is available
larger.
Porcelain is used in virtually all types of installations, from schools to
corporations. Porcelain is produced as a chalkboard or a markerboard
finish. The finishes are produced by coating a ceramic (glass) finish to
a steel sheet and baking it (similar to a charcoal grill or sink finish).
There are more colors available with the chalkboard finish. The dry erase
porcelain is available in white, beige and gray (custom colors can be
produced). Since it is glass, porcelain can chip if it is cut or
sheared. This chipping will not allow for clean seams. Seams are
typically finished with an unattractive H-Bar molding. The main advantage
that porcelain offers is that it is highly scratch resistant, and that it
has a lifetime of the building guarantee. Porcelain is available in four
feet widths. Some manufacturers offer boards up to 4’ x 16’, but these
are difficult to ship. Advantages of the
Markawall
products are the following: 1) seams are virtually invisible like
wallcovering, 2) there is not a problem shipping
markawall,
since it is shipped in a small container, and it will fit in any elevator,
3) long seamless surfaces are only available with the
markawall
products, and 4) the ability to cover complete walls with horizontal seams
to move the seams out of the main writing area.
2.
Can you project on melamine or porcelain?
Yes
you can - but you will see a definite “hot spot” or glare. This “hot
spot” can be described as the concentrated bright spot on the surface.
MarkaWalls’
nu×vu×wall
does not have a hot spot or glare when projecting.
Erase×wall
will have a very slight glow when it is used as a projection screen.
Just×wall
and
mag×wall
have a slightly lower gloss than porcelain.
Ez×wall
and melamine have similar gloss levels (high) that lower projection
quality.
3.
Who generally purchases porcelain products?
Porcelain is used in all applications. It is typically not used for
smaller boards (under 3’ x 4’), unless these boards are installed as part
of the contract with the other boards. Porcelain chalkboards are
typically used in grade and middle schools. Markerboards are becoming the
surface of choice for all grades, including colleges, with the use of more
and more computers in classrooms.
|